Tropics of discourse essays in cultural criticism

If one assumes a base level of honesty and skill on the part of the historian, White finds no reason to privilege one historical account over another based only on historical evidence.

In several of his works, White argues that historical studies are best understood not as accurate and objective representations of the past but as creative texts structured by narrative and rhetorical devices that shape historical interpretation. Hence, the pattern is set; the theorists are aligned or where they are not, they at least offer an alternative and complimentary look at one another.

Hayden White Critical Essays

In addition, White has been attacked by historians for his lack of attention to historical context within his own works. Each of these figures has its own characteristic way of organizing pieces of information into a larger whole.

White American historian, critic, essayist, and editor. A prominent American historian, White is known for his analysis of the literary structures of the works of nineteenth- and twentieth-century historians and philosophers. Jul 13, Cristina rated it liked it Recommends it for: We thrive on questions perhaps even more than we thrive on answers, and it is namely the more problematic issues--culture, society, and history, among others--that intrigue and baffle us.

In Metahistory, White sets out the interpretive framework that guides much of his later work. Although his work has drawn criticism from historians and literary critics alike, White is widely respected for raising vital questions about the latent assumptions that inform all kinds of historical interpretation.

For White, fictitious and historiographical events are both conveyed through similar representational strategies and hence, at this formal level, no differences exist between these two kinds of discourse.

White later became professor of history at Rochester and served as the departmental chairperson from to In Tropics of Discourse, White strives to develop a less relativistic stance by arguing that the deep structures that define human consciousness have a certain stability that allows for the creation of sound representations of human perceptions of reality.

Human nature has made us curious, cerebral beings. While White is widely respected as a thorough and wide-ranging scholar, many have faulted him for problems posed by his methodology.

Tropics of discourse : essays in cultural criticism

Essays in Cultural Criticism, Hayden White discusses the problems and promises of history. Full name Hayden V.

White asserts that the kind of history one chooses to tell is based on moral and aesthetic values that stand in sharp contrast to some objective, neutral understanding of historical evidence alone.

White also examines the difficulties and ethical problems posed in finding effective ways to represent the Holocaust. White left the University of Rochester in to take a position as a history professor at the University of California, Los Angeles, where he remained until The final result of Tropics of Discourse is an artful use of the tropes to indicate their function as the signs and stages in the evolution of human consciousness, and how this consciousness evaluates history.

In the three collections of essays published since the appearance of Metahistory, White has sought to elaborate and modify his approach and to respond to his critics.

After serving as an instructor of history at Wayne State from toWhite worked as an assistant professor of history at the University of Rochester in Rochester, New York, in Critics have accused White of adhering to a rigid formalism that denies the plurality of forms of historical writing.

Tropics of Discourse: Essays in Cultural Criticism

InWhite accepted a position as director for the Center for the Humanities at Wesleyan University in Connecticut, where he was named Kenan Professor from to In collaboration with other scholars, White served as an editor of the two-volume work The Emergence of Liberal Humanism, The Uses of Historyand Giambattista Vico He also suggests that it is not possible for some pieces of historical evidence to be represented within particular tropological structures, and hence the historian needs to rely only on those modes of discourse that will most accurately reflect the evidence in question.

Despite these sustained critiques, White continues to be widely respected among scholars in a variety of fields and for raising thought-provoking questions that have influenced the direction of historical inquiry in the late twentieth century. Influenced by eighteenth-century scholar Giambattista Vico and literary critic Kenneth Burke, White proposes a theory of tropes, or symbolic modes, that constitutes the deep structure of historical thought.

Hayden White

In Tropics of Discourse: In this third stage, the relationship between the presumed essence and its superficial attributes will be, White insists, revealed. We must grapple with it throughout existence, pass this grappling down through generations just as we have inherited it, and attempt to make sense of our experiences as best we can.

While at Wesleyan, White produced his first major work, Metahistory, and continued to publish essays about problems of historical knowledge and the relations between history and literature in journals and edited volumes.

In Figural Realisma collection of essays written since publication of The Content of the Form, White elaborated on his arguments about tropes and responds to some of his critics.

White left Connecticut in to accept a position as professor of the history of consciousness at the University of California, Santa Cruz, where he has since remained. Thus, for White, the power of these different modes of representation highlights the non-scientific nature of the discipline of history.

Nov 15, Zacharygs rated it really liked it Good selection of essay, first few are rather outstanding.Find helpful customer reviews and review ratings for Tropics of Discourse: Essays in Cultural Criticism at Read honest.

Essays and criticism on Hayden White - Critical Essays. Metahistory in two collections of essays, Tropics of Discourse develop a deeper understanding of.

Tropics of discourse: essays in cultural criticism Item Preview remove-circle Topics Cultural studies, Discourse analysis, Semiotics & Theory, Historiography, Sociology, Literary Criticism, Internet Archive Books.

Scanned in China.

Tropics of Discourse

Hayden White (July 12, – March 5, ) was an American historian in the tradition of literary criticism, perhaps most famous for his work Metahistory: The Historical Imagination in Nineteenth-Century Europe (/).

"Tropics of Discourse" develops White's ideas on interpretation in history, on the relationship between history and the novel, and on history and historicism. Vico, Croce, Derrida, and Foucault are among the figures he assesses in this work, which also offers original interpretations of a number of literary themes, including the Wild Man and the.

Tropics of Discourse: Essays in Cultural Criticism / Edition 1 Tropics of Discourse develops White's ideas on interpretation in history, on the relationship between history and the novel, and on history and $

Tropics of discourse essays in cultural criticism
Rated 4/5 based on 88 review